Professor Michel Kaiser is a well-respected leading fisheries conservation scientist at Heriot-Watt University in the UK, whose research focuses on sustainable fisheries management and reducing the environmental impacts of fishing. His work highlights the importance of balancing commercial fishing activities with the protection of marine ecosystems, fish populations and biodiversity.
He has produced a 36 min video to summarise the science on bottom trawling 101Trawling - What the science says
'Trawling is one of the most debated ways we produce food, and one of the most misunderstood. Bottom trawling alone supplies about a quarter of the world’s wild-caught seafood, and that’s before counting midwater pelagic trawl fisheries such as Alaska pollock or Altantic mackerel. Many hundreds of millions of people around the world rely on fishing for food and livelihoods. I’ve spent more than 30 years researching how trawling affects the seabed and wider ecosystem. The science is well developed, and it tells a more nuanced story than the one people usually hear:
Most of the world’s continental shelves are sediment habitats that recover relatively quickly. Sensitive habitats such as reefs and coral gardens need protecting, and many already are.
Management makes the difference. In well-managed regions such as southern Chile and Alaska, most of the seabed is untouched by trawling. Where trawling does occur, most seabed life remains intact.
The best-managed trawl fisheries have a remarkably low carbon footprint. For example, Alaska pollock comes close to farming potatoes.
Innovation keeps raising the bar, from dredges that halve seabed contact to AI-enabled “smart” trawls that let unwanted fish swim free.
Banning trawling wouldn’t make the world’s need for protein go away. It would shift production onto land, often at far greater cost to biodiversity, and put many livelihoods at risk. For anyone who wants to look at the evidence, I’ve recorded a plain-language explainer (well, 36 minutes of one....there is a lot to this topic) for you to digest and I plan to follow up with some shorter deep dives on different areas. I’d welcome questions and challenges in the comments.'
Links to the literature:
Understanding the consequences of trawl contact on the seabed (part 1) https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1618858114
Understanding the consequences of trawl contact on the seabed (part 2) https://doi.org/10.1111/faf.12283
Quantifying global fishing footprint on the seabed https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1802379115
Calculating the health status of seabed life subject to trawling https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2109449119
The seabed carbon trawl debate https://rdcu.be/DEYZ1qx3kzwa
Comparing trawl caught food to other food production systems https://doi.org/10.1093/icesjms/fsad115